Live events go virtual, corporate marketers become publishers and old school media gets conversational. It's old news that the Web turned publishing upside down; now the only question is how fast traditional media can learn to dance with its feet stuck to the ceiling.Considering
it is a non-profit for a business-to-business media industry that is being
decimated by the internet, the American Business Media (ABM) association can
surprise you sometimes.
At
last week's Digital
Velocity 2009, an event billed as a lesson
in how to get a return-on-investment in a digital-media economy, necessity
caused ABM to invent a new event format.
And
the content presented in that new format showed how far and fast social media
and the Web are changing journalism and business marketing, at two very
different ends of the media spectrum.
Rather
than stick with the traditional event plan after it became clear that the
economic crisis would limit in-person attendance to a small fraction of the
crowd that filled last year’s event, ABM canceled the physical edition. But it
convinced two keynoters and other panelists to go ahead and present anyway.
Keynoter
John Yemma is editor of the Christian Science Monitor (CSM), as
old-school a daily as you might find, but he talked about a Web-first strategy
that eliminates the daily paper edition in favor of a weekly. And Peter Hahn,
Bearingpoint’s interactive marketing manager, proved that branded content
marketing has hit the mainstream by quoting the company’s “publish or perish”
mantra.
Yemma
and Hahn were broadcast via live streaming video-over-the-Web March 3,
presenting to roughly 30 people in ABM’s conference room in Manhattan and
nobody-knows-how-many at 49 locations that tuned in across the country.
Dragonfly,
one of the event sponsors, provided the streaming. A simple teleconference
provided the interactive link back to the conference room for Q&A.
The
panel sessions from the conference’s original agenda will be broadcast in
coming weeks, and all the video will be archived on the ABM site for on-demand
viewing. All the video, cut into roughly 10-minute segments, can be seen now
from ABM’s home page.
Appropriately,
Yemma began his talk with an allusion to Stanford University economist Paul
Romer’s famous quote, “a crisis is a terrible thing to waste.”
He
talked about CSM’s plan to cease daily print publication in favor of a
weekly edition, and focus the paper’s roughly three dozen journalists in eight
international bureaus on breaking news for the Web site.
The
weekly print edition will be reserved for in-depth analysis. Content production
will be carved into three separate and self-contained operations: Web, email
newsletter and print.
When
technology B2B publishers tried the same production approach, however, they
were stymied.
I
know this first-hand because I tried it while heading up a B2B media group at
CMP Media. It turned out that even top-notch print editorial managers viewed it
as career suicide to be associated only with print. The publisher ended up with
one integrated production team, whether optimal or not.
When
asked about his staff’s reaction, Yemma said no one raised any objection.
But
Yemma, who characterized CSM as “the Economist with a heart,”
said the affect of the Internet on traditional media that concerns him most is
the “breakup of the Fourth Estate.
“The
fourth estate as an actual institution is breaking up. It’s not the power
center that it was. That has tremendous implications for society, it has
tremendous implications for democracy,” Yemma said.
He
acknowledged the emerging role of bloggers and citizen journalists, but worried
that they would not possess the resources necessary to provide the kind of
checks against government, corporate and other corruption and wrongdoing that
news publications have traditionally provided.
“It’s
not like there is a lot we can do about it, other than cope with it, I
believe,” he added. “But if you are in the fourth estate you have to figure out
new ways of telling stories. And if you are in businesses that market with or
use the channels in or through the fourth estate, you have to figure out a
thousand new ways to deliver your messages. That’s the new world we live in.”
Bearingpoint
is making do in that new media world by joining it. “I’m a marketer, and I’m a
publisher,” Hahn told the group. “I publish the ideas of the 15,000 people in
my company. There are a lot of marketers who think the way that I do.” In fact,
if marketers haven’t started to ramp up their content engines yet, he said, then
they are behind the curve.
Social
media and user content are a big part of Bearingpoint’s mix, according to Hahn.
The company has Facebook fans, Twitter followers and a corporate blog.
“Command-and-control
media are dead,” he said. “You have to be what your audience is
interested in.”
Hahn
said he wants to make Bearingpoint’s Web site the place his audience of
customers and prospects can go for the content that is important to them, no
matter where on the Web it was originally published.
Yemma
also spoke of content aggregation and user-generated content, saying that those
strategies would be part of a second wave of change from CSM.
“Web-first
is the first stage of the strategy. That’s still push journalism. Beyond that
our next big strategic move is to develop a really robust social media
strategy, so that we’re developing more of a community around this content,” he
said. “We’re looking at horizontally moving across the Internet and creating a
coalition of like-minded organizations.”
When
I described these discussions to a B2B media veteran I know, he thought it was
ironic that the “marketing guy” seemed to be further down the curve of Web
media trends than the journalist.
I
hadn’t even noticed; I’ve become immune, I guess, to the glacial pace at which
traditional media businesses are capable of change. It’s a scary, provocative
thought, but marketers seem destined to play a significant role in the
journalism of the future.
During
the roundtable discussion, hot topics among Yemma, Hahn and their audience of
B2B executives included whether newspapers “can turn back the clock on the
‘news-is-free’ mentality,” as Yemma put it.
Debate
on this topic is currently raging through the net, sparked by Walter Isaacson’s
Time magazine story, “How to Save
Your Newspaper.” Another was the way in which
measuring reporting staff by their traffic production skews news away from
“important stories” toward “the lowest common denominator.”
“On
the other hand, if you have an investigative piece that you have spent a long
time developing and no one is reading it, what’s the point of that?” Yemma
asked.
Mike
Azzara is a longtime B2B media executive covering the high-technology industry,
now heading up the branded content marketing arm of Stein Rogan + Partners. He
also advises media software start-up mSpoke, and
tries his best to consult with media companies beginning to deal with internet
affects he’s already lived through – but they insist on making the same
mistakes on their own.