Photo - Publish.com
Publish.com Ziff-Davis Enterprise  
SEARCH · ONLINE MEDIA · MOBILE · WEB DESIGN · GRAPHICS TOOLS · PRINTING · PHOTO · TIPS · OPINIONS
Home arrow Photo arrow COMMENTARY: The persistence of scanners
COMMENTARY: The persistence of scanners
By Bill Howard

Rate This Article:
Add This Article To:
Scanning lives and even thrives, despite the proliferation of e-mail for communication.

Around the heyday of the Model T 80 years ago, this column might have started out, "Buggy whips have never been more versatile or useful than they are now." And the parallel today might be, "Document and business-card scanners remain a valuable and increasingly affordable tool for business and personal productivity."

So let's say it: Scanning lives and even thrives, despite the proliferation of e-mail for communication. Hardware prices are coming down and scanning software has gotten smarter. Odds are that that blue-ink-on-yellow-paper invoice you never could scan properly two years ago now scans perfectly on the first pass. And it's likely stored in an open format that will be with us a century from now: the PDF.

The biggest change for the better has been the availability of Kofax VRS (VirtualReScan) software in affordable—now sub-$500 —document and personal scanners, despite the software's costing $500-plus were you to buy it alone. VRS figures out the best way to knock out colored and gray-shaded backgrounds while increasing the legibility of text and writing even when it's not black ink on the original. Think of VRS as an add-on to other scanning software, not a replacement.

The most impressive scanner I've worked with lately is the Xerox DocuMate 252, about $980 street. It uses Scansoft PaperPort for scanning and file management, plus Scansoft TextBridge for optical character recognition, and Kofax VRS for tough-situations scanning. As with nearly all document scanners costing more than $500 these days, it has two CCD scan heads so it can read both sides of a document at once (and discard blank back sides if desired). It scans 25 sheets or 50 sides a minute. By year's end you may see auto-duplex scanners for well under $500.

Visioneer recently released a VRS-enabled version of its Visioneer Strobe XP 200, a sheet-fed (one sheet at a time by hand) scanner for $400 street, $100 more than the non-VRS version. Current Strobe XP 200 owners can upgrade to the VRS software for the $100 price difference—a reasonable price for all the time you'll save.

Scanning hardware and software remain cantankerous. PaperPort software, even in its ninth version, still has quirks. So does VRS. For instance, on the DocuMate 252 I could create a front-panel preset to scan in 300 dpi with a filter to remove a red background, but it resisted my best efforts to implement the blue- and green-background filters at 300 dpi monochrome. The auto-crop button—useful when you're scanning a receipt—remained grayed out; it turns out that it hasn't actually been implemented yet.

For scanners with automatic document feeders (ADF), you need to pull out staples and paper clips (obviously), riffle the stack so you don't get two sheets fed as one, then babysit the ADF output tray (so the papers don't skew and eventually spill onto the floor). So even if you can load 50 sheets in the ADF, you can't just walk away and come back a couple minutes later. If there's a gray background, VRS does a great job making the type legible. But the shading creates a huge document, often 600Kb for a sheet scanned at 300 dpi, which you can knock back to less than half of that by manually using the Remove Stray Dots button.

Business card scanners are coming down in price too. Corex, the best-known of the brands (Iris, Visioneer, and Targus also sell them), now has a USB-powered scanner, the Corex 700C, which correctly scans most business cards that don't have an oddball (or italic) font. Its free online AccuCard service e-mails the card image back to the card owner for corrections. AccuCard is a great concept that could sink as users worry if the AccuCard e-mail is another online scam. (It's not.) The 700C's typical street price is around $250; it makes more sense when it's on sale in the $150 to $200 range.

While you can find a slew of flatbed scanners for less than $100 that do a great job with photos, there's no affordable negative or slide scanner. (Even if there were, scanning your old negatives can be a huge time sink.) Nor are there many affordable 11-by-17 or tabloid-size scanners for graphic artists (the tabloid Microtek ScanMaker 9800XL runs $1,400), although stitching software is adequate for the occasional big document. For photos, your best bet is to get a flatbed scanner with an ADF (HP, Visioneer, others), run your prints through at 100 dpi, and use those as a proof sheet quality guide to your pictures (or for passable display on screen or on a TV screen), then have your best images scanned professionally (if you can't find a friend with a film scanner, preferably one with automatic scratch reduction).




Discuss COMMENTARY: The persistence of scanners
 
>>> Be the FIRST to comment on this article!
 

 
 
>>> More Photo Articles          >>> More By Bill Howard
 


Buyer's Guide
Explore hundreds of products in our Publish.com Buyer's Guide.
Web design
Content management
Graphics Software
Streaming Media
Video
Digital photography
Stock photography
Web development
View all >

ADVERTISEMENT


FREE ZIFF DAVIS ENTERPRISE ESEMINARS AT ESEMINARSLIVE.COM
  • Dec 10, 4 p.m. ET
    Eliminate the Drawbacks of Traditional Backup/Replication for Linux
    with Michael Krieger. Sponsored by InMage
  • Dec 11, 1 p.m. ET
    Data Modeling and Metadata Management with PowerDesigner
    with Joel Shore. Sponsored by Sybase
  • Dec 12, 12 p.m. ET
    Closing the IT Business Gap: Monitoring the End-User Experience
    with Michael Krieger. Sponsored by Compuware
  • Dec 12, 2 p.m. ET
    Enabling IT Consolidation
    with Michael Krieger. Sponsored by Riverbed & VMWare
  • VTS
    Join us on Dec. 19 for Discovering Value in Stored Data & Reducing Business Risk. Join this interactive day-long event to learn how your enterprise can cost-effectively manage stored data while keeping it secure, compliant and accessible. Disorganized storage can prevent your enterprise from extracting the maximum value from information assets. Learn how to organize enterprise data so vital information assets can help your business thrive. Explore policies, strategies and tactics from creation through deletion. Attend live or on-demand with complimentary registration!
    FEATURED CONTENT
    IT LINK DISCUSSION - MIGRATION
    A Windows Vista® migration introduces new and unique challenges to any IT organization. It's important to understand early on whether your systems, hardware, applications and end users are ready for the transition.
    Join the discussion today!



    .NAME Charging For Whois
    Whois has always been a free service, but the .NAME registry is trying to change that.
    Read More >>

    Sponsored by Ziff Davis Enterprise Group

    NEW FROM ZIFF DAVIS ENTERPRISE


    Delivering the latest technology news & reviews straight to your handheld device

    Now you can get the latest technology news & reviews from the trusted editors of eWEEK.com on your handheld device
    mobile.eWEEK.com

     


    RSS 2.0 Feed


    internet
    rss graphic Publish.com
    rss graphic Google Watch

    Video Interviews


    streaming video
    Designing Apps for Usability
    DevSource interviews usability pundit Dr. Jakob Nielsen on everything from the proper attitude for programmers to the importance of prototyping in design to the reasons why PDF, Flash and local search engines can hurt more than they help.
    ADVERTISEMENT